[Ambroise Vollard (1839–1906), Paris, by late 19th century]. Ivan Ivanovich Shchukin (1869–1908), Moscow and Paris, from at least October 1899 (sale, Paris, Hôtel Drouot, 24 March 1900, lot 4).(1) Josse and Gaston Bernheim-Jeune, Paris, from at least 1919 to 1930;(2) Gaston Bernheim de Villers, Paris, from 1930, still in 1949. [Sam Salz, New York, by c. 1949–50, probably sold about January 1951 to]; William (1903–1969) and Edith Mayer (1905–1988) Goetz, Los Angeles (sale, London, Sotheby’s, 14 October 1970, lot 4, to);(3) [A. de Vidal, possibly for];(4) Mario de Botton (1909–1992), London (sale, New York, Christie’s, 13 November 1984, lot 129, to); A. J. Perenchio (1930–2017), Los Angeles, gifted 2025 to; Los Angeles County Museum of Art
Footnotes
(1) The Commissaire-priseur G. Duchesne’s Minutes and Procèsverbal for this sale lists Shchukin as the seller and provides information on his financial difficulties. Scholar, critic, and art collector, Shchukin led an overly extravagant lifestyle and squandered his fortune. His lack of support from his family, particularly from his brother Sergei (1854–1936), a well-known collector of Henri Matisse and an early patron of modern art, forced Ivan to place his collection on the market. In so doing he discovered that a number of his Spanish paintings (El Greco and Goya, primarily) were forgeries. Desperate and unable to pay his bills, Ivan killed himself on 2 January 1908.
(2) According to Jayne Warman, “In 1930 Josse and Gaston divided their collection—Gaston kept this canvas (this information from a letter dated March 25, 1981 to John Rewald from Gilbert Gruet, who worked for many years at Bernheim-Jeune)” (email to Patricia Teter-Schneider, 28 July 2015). According to Bernheim-Jeune & Cie, the painting was in the personal collection of Josse and Gaston Bernheim-Jeune, and consequently was not logged in the stock of the gallery, and therefore they are unable to provide further information regarding the picture (letter from Guy-Patrice Dauberville to Leah Lehmbeck, 16 December 2015).
(3) Film producer William Goetz and his wife Edith, the daughter of the film mogul Louis B. Mayer, were part of Hollywood’s heyday, and by the 1940s they had started amassing what would become one of the finest West Coast collections of Impressionist and modern art. In addition to this Cézanne, the Goetzes owned Bonnard’s After the Meal, cat. 2.
(4) Sotheby’s price and buyer sheet for the 14 October 1970 Goetz sale lists “A. de Vidal” as the buyer for lot 4, however the buyer has been verified by Sotheby’s as Mario de Botton (email to Patricia Teter-Schneider, 27 July 2015). A. de Vidal also purchased lots 7 by Dufy and 14 by Renoir, however it is uncertain if the other lots were also intended for Mario de Botton.