(Sale, Paris, Pierre Remy, 26 Mar. 1765, "Catalogue de dessins, tableaux, et estampes après le décès de M. Deshays," lot 105, as Saint André adorant la croix sur laquelle il doit être martyrisé, with possibly lot 107, sold for 49 livres 1 sol to); Abbé Gruel (or Gruelle). (Sale, Paris, Basan, 5 Nov. 1781, "Catalogue de tableaux, dessins et estampes des plus grands mais-tres des trois écoles italienne, flamande et française, provenans du cabinet de M.***," lot 44. One of two sketches sold as "The Martyrdoms of St. Lawrence and St. Andrew)." Marie Bigot de Graveron, Présidente de Bandeville (sale, Paris, Pierre Remy, 3 Dec. 1787, lot 62, sold for 46 livres 19 sols to);(1) "Glamont" (or "Hamont" or "Blamont"). Art market, Paris; Andrew S. Ciechanowiecki (1924–2015), London, by 1973, sold 2000 to; LACMA.
Footnote
(1) The Bandeville sale lists a pair of paintings: "Deux Esquisses differément composées du Martyr de Saint André, Etudes faites pour les tableaux en grand qui sont à Saint André de Rouen; elles sont peintes sur toile & portent chaque 19 pouces et 6 lines de haut sur 10 pouces de large." It seems likely that the paintings were bought as a pair from the Deshays sale and kept together as a pair through at least this sale.